VAR Error Overshadows Manchester City’s 1–0 Derby Victory Manchester City defeated Manchester United 1–0 at Old Trafford on Sunday, September 13, despite playing for more than an hour with ten men. Erling Haaland scored the only goal of the 199th Manchester derby in the 60th minute after Phil Foden had been sent off during the first half. However, the victory became the subject of controversy when refereeing body Pro Ref acknowledged after the match that VAR had mishandled the decision to award Haaland’s goal. Reuters’ report on the VAR admission Foden dismissed in the first half The match changed dramatically in the 23rd minute when Foden was shown a red card for kicking out at Bruno Fernandes. City responded by dropping into a more compact defensive structure. United were given more possession but struggled to translate their numerical advantage into clear opportunities. Marcus Rashford came closest before halftime when his free kick struck the post. Kobbie Mainoo then hit the woodwork with a long-range attempt six minutes after the restart. Those chances suggested United were beginning to increase the pressure, but City struck moments later. Haaland scores after lengthy review Joško Gvardiol delivered a cross toward the far post, where Haaland finished from a tight angle. The assistant referee initially raised the flag for offside. A lengthy review established that Patrick Dorgu’s outstretched foot had played Haaland onside. The review also examined Enzo Fernández, who attempted to reach the cross while standing in an offside position. Fernández did not touch the ball, and VAR decided that his movement had not interfered with Lisandro Martínez’s attempt to defend the delivery. The goal was therefore awarded. City protected the lead, with Gianluigi Donnarumma producing an important stoppage-time save to deny Bryan Mbeumo. The result left City second in the table with 12 points from four matches, behind Arsenal on goal difference. United remained 13th with four points. Reuters’ match report Refereeing body acknowledges mistake Pro Ref later stated that the VAR had failed to recognise the likely impact of Fernández’s position on Martínez. Because Fernández did not play the ball, determining whether he interfered with an opponent became a subjective offside decision. Pro Ref said the VAR should have recommended that referee Michael Oliver review the incident using the pitchside monitor. The organisation contacted Manchester United to acknowledge what it described as an “error of judgement” and confirmed that the incident would be reviewed. That admission does not alter the official result. Manchester City remain 1–0 winners, and Haaland’s goal remains recorded in the match statistics. It does, however, confirm that the review process was not handled correctly. City’s response deserves recognition The disputed goal should not completely obscure City’s performance after Foden’s dismissal. Enzo Maresca’s side remained organised, protected central spaces and restricted United to three shots on target. Haaland also registered his ninth goal in 11 Manchester derby appearances. Manchester City’s official highlights report United had opportunities, particularly through Rashford and Mainoo, but their attacking play lacked sufficient speed and movement against City’s compact defensive block. City appeared comfortable allowing United to circulate possession in less dangerous areas. When the hosts approached the penalty box, defenders closed the spaces between the lines and limited clean shooting opportunities. That tactical assessment is independent FootyTactix analysis. A difficult result for United Michael Carrick can reasonably feel frustrated about the decisive decision, especially following Pro Ref’s admission. At the same time, United played most of the match with an extra player and still failed to score. The refereeing error and United’s attacking shortcomings can both be true. City demonstrated greater composure after going down to ten men, while United lacked the creativity required to break through a disciplined defensive structure. The result maintains City’s perfect Premier League start under Maresca. For United, four points from four matches represents an uncertain opening despite the progress made under Carrick last season. The VAR controversy will dominate the immediate reaction, but both managers will also recognise the footballing lessons produced by an intense afternoon at Old Trafford. FootyTactix note: The result, match events, league positions and refereeing admission were verified using reports published on September 13, 2026. Tactical observations are independent analysis and do not represent guaranteed future outcomes.
Related articles
Share this article
Explore today’s predictions
Review the latest match analysis and free selections from FootyTactix.
View Predictions
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to join the conversation.